Discussion 5 - Caster S. case

Discussion #5 Caster S. case

It seems that the argument being made by the Olympic Committee is that it is unfair for her to compete against other females because she has a biological advantage.   I wonder what the response would be if you looked at it a bit differently.  It sure seems to me that Lebron James has a biological advantage over most of the other players in the league.  Should he be allowed to compete in that league?  Shouldn't they make a different league for people who are so much bigger, stronger, and faster than everyone else?  Isn't that a similar logic?

Reference:

What is the controversy about Caster Semenya?   What does that suggest about the "naturalness" of sex and/or "gender"?   How can/should the determination be made?