Discussion - What is your reaction to the data presented

Discussion Prompts

1)  What is your reaction to the data presented in this chapter about the relationship between immigration and crime? Are these data surprising? Not surprising? Do you think these data are reflected in most people's views of immigration issues? Why or why not?

2)  How do you feel about the involvement of local and state law enforcement in the enforcement of federal immigration law? Do the potential benefits outweigh the costs or the costs outweigh the benefits? Why?

• There are several resources in the "Optional Content: Links and Further Readings" section of the module that may help inform your argument for prompt 2. All the links and articles from the "ICE Overview of the 287(g) program" down to the bottom of the list are related to this issue. The Police Foundation (2009)provides a direct discussion of pros and cons (although it is a bit dated).