Contemplation and Consideration

Contemplation and Consideration

Some people believe that you can tell who a person is by what they do when no one is looking. Let's look at the following case. John Doe, a nurse, has downloaded an application to her phone that allows him to download copyrighted textbooks for a nursing course (that Doe is going to take) without his Internet Service Provider knowing it. The application is called "Cloak" as in cloak of invisibility (a hooded coat one wears to make it so others cannot see you). The application disguises his phone and makes it so the information on it is inaccessible. John is aware that other people who are of a lower socio-economic status (like him) also use this software program for the same reason (and to save money). John Doe knows that his religion forbids him from using this application to download in this manner. John Doe is focused on his own economic situation and does not consider the publisher, author, and others involved in the books. Think about a course of social action; what social values should be used to address this moral issue and conflict.

Question:

What if John Doe, upon being confronted about his activities, replies that having been accepted to his class, and payed the tuition, it is incumbent on the class to provide him with what he needs to take the class, and not include "stealth tuition that punish the poor,"  such as having to buy overpriced texts from the University's bookstore?

Does this effect the ethical calculation?

APA format at least 250 words