Question
Offered Price $10.00

Reformation and Political Authority

Question # 00006330
Subject: History
Due on: 09/30/2014
Posted On: 01/09/2014 01:53 PM

Rating:
4.1/5
Expert tutors with experiences and qualities
Posted By
Best Tutors for school students, college students
Questions:
966
Tutorials:
1038
Feedback Score:

Purchase it
Report this Question as Inappropriate
Question

Reformation and Political Authority

The following passage was written in the twelfth century by a Dominican Priest named John of Paris. Read this and consider what it tells us about the later dispute between the political power of Church versus State.

Secular power is more diverse, because of the diversity of climates and physical constitutions. Secondly, because one man alone cannot rule the world in temporal affairs as can one alone in spiritual affairs. Spiritual power can easily extend its sanction to everyone, near and far, since it is verbal. Secular power, however, cannot so easily extend its sword very far, since it is wielded by hand. It is far easier to extend verbal than physical authority. Third, because the temporalities of laymen are not communal...; each is master of his own property as acquired through his own industry. There is no need therefore for one to administer temporalities in common since each is his own administrator to do with his own what he wishes. On the other hand, ecclesiastical property was given to the [Christian] community as a whole... (pp. 85-6).

J.A. Watt. (n.d.). John of Paris
Retrieved from
.fordham.edu/Halsall/source/johnparis-y67s14a.asp">http://www.fordham.edu/Halsall/source/johnparis-y67s14a.asp

The next passage was written by Marsilius of Padua in 1324. It is part of a longer list of “truths” about the nature of authority. Consider again what it tells us about disputes of power during the later Reformation.

There can be only one supreme ruling power in a state or kingdom.

The number and the qualifications of persons who hold state offices and all civil matters are to be determined solely by the Christian ruler according to the law or approved custom [of the state].

No prince, no partial council, nor single person of any position, has full authority and control over other persons, laymen or clergy, without the authorization of the legislator.

No bishop or priest has coercive authority or jurisdiction over any layman or clergyman, even if he is a heretic.

The prince who rules by the authority of the "legislator" has jurisdiction over the persons and possessions of every single mortal of every station, whether lay or clerical, and over every body of laymen or clergy.

No bishop or priest or body of bishops or priests has the authority to excommunicate anyone or to interdict the performance of divine services, without the authorization of the "legislator."

Paul Halsall. (1996). Medieval Sourcebook: Marsiligio of Padua: Conclusions from Defensor Pacis, 1324
Retrieved from
.fordham.edu/Halsall/source/marsiglio1.asp">http://www.fordham.edu/Halsall/source/marsiglio1.asp

Question: Both of these works enjoyed a resurgence during the religious conflict of the sixteenth century. How would these arguments be used to support or challenge a break between the political king and the spiritual center in Rome? Be sure to mention which passage would support Catholic goals and which would support Protestant reforms. Write 200 - 250 words

Tags authority political reformation authority power support spiritual extend persons priest laymen political paage state verbal christian affairs century jurisdiction hand temporalities padua retrieved 0 property prince body written easily john tells paris authorization

Tutorials for this Question
Available for
$10.00

RESURGENCE DURING THE RELIGIOUS CONFLICT OF THE SIXTEENTH CENTURY(100% PERFECT ANSWER)

Tutorial # 00006062
Posted On: 01/09/2014 01:55 PM
Posted By:
Best Tutors for school students, college students sharpbrain
Expert tutors with experiences and qualities
Questions:
966
Tutorials:
1038
Feedback Score:
Report this Tutorial as Inappropriate
Tutorial Preview …incorporate xx their xxxx (R W xxxxxxxxx 1970) Locals xxxxx their xxxxxxx xxx traditions xxxxx overridden by xxx decrees of xxxxxxx who xxxx xx involved xx their daily xxxxxxx Leaders of…
Attachments
RESURGENCE_DURING_THE_RELIGIOUS_CONFLICT_OF_THE_SIXTEENTH_CENTURY.doc (24.5 KB)
Preview: sure xx mention xxxxx passage would xxxxxxx Catholic goals xxx which xxxxx xxxxxxx Protestant xxxxxxx Answer to xxx student During xxx 16th xxxxxxx x movement xxxxx through the xxxxxxxxx provinces of xxx European xxxxxxxxx xxxx movement xxxxx as a xxxxxxxx between the xxxxx emerging xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx the xxxxx governments they xxxxx to incorporate xx their xxxx xx W xxxxxxxxx 1970) Locals xxxxx their customs xxx traditions xxxxx xxxxxxxxxx by xxx decrees of xxxxxxx who were xx.....
Purchase this Tutorial @ $10.00 *
* - Additional Paypal / Transaction Handling Fee (3.9% of Tutorial price + $0.30) applicable
Loading...